Cheap Music Romance, Vol. 1: Music for Children (Music) (Greg Cohen, Erik Friedlander, John Zorn, Marc Ribot, Cyro Baptista, William Winant, Julie Steinberg, David Abel) Price

Related Products

Customer Reviews of Music Romance, Vol. 1: Music for Children

MPD Zorn
This CD nicely compacts the range of John Zorn. With pieces like "Bikini Atoll" and "Bone Crusher," Zorn shows his thrash side, also giving Prelapse, a sharp little band who would bill themselves as performers of "John Zorn's unrecorded music," a little nod with their first recorded outing. (It may be out of print, but if possible, score yourself Prelapse's Avant release.) "Cycles du Nord" exemplifies the Morton Feldman-esque Zorn, as he manipulates wind machines and acoustic feedback systems for over 20 minutes. There's "Dreamer of Dreams," which brings out the jazzy Zorn, the one that let Naked City jam and not just thrash, and then there is, of course, the quick-change Zorn with the title track. All this mixed in with the creepy element of Zorn, as "Fils des Etoiles," "This Way Out" and "SooKi's Lullaby," juxtaposed with the rather horrific and at least somewhat sexualized images of young bodies in the insert artwork, make simple-sounding tunes, as though for children, make one want to hide the little ones. <
> <
>Of course, one could say that this is all the culmination of the vast musical intellect of John Zorn and that there really IS no distinction from one piece to another (and this may be supported by the title, which suggests that this is all just a single volume of Music Romance), and while Prelapse is certainly the second coming of Naked City (and perhaps a little more enthusiastic), and classic names like William Winant and Anthony Coleman and Marc Ribot bring depth to the playing on this disc, there is something ultimately disjointed about this collection. Perhaps I am just not seeing the ultimate connection, and maybe that is my own failing, but this disc fails to deliver its final commonality in the end. <
>

---

Varied collection.
An album of unnerving variation, "Music For Children" is a collection of compositions by John Zorn that seem unrelated but somehow fit together. The album consists of two extended works, three hardcore miniatures left over from Naked City's "Torture Garden", and three mid-length compositions. <
> <
>The extended compositions end up being the most difficult, the title track, "Music For Children", is a scored for violin (David Abel), piano (Julie Steinberg) and percussion (William Winant). It's one of the more difficult of Zorn's classical pieces, scored in small, seemingly unrelated blocks (of what someone else referred to as cartoon music, though I don't her it), playing silence and the instruments off of each other. It's a thoroughly enjoyable listen, but it hasn't sunk in with me yet just what's going on. But as odd as "Music For Children" is, it's nothing compared to "Cycles du Nord". A tribute to Edgard Varese (an early pioneer of electronic music), Zorn performs on "three wind machines and two acoustic feedback systems", and sonically it sounds like standing in a staggeringly windy city street for twenty minutes-- there's an occasional noise beneath the wind that's hard to make out, and sometimes feedback swells, but by and large it's all about wind. Remarkably, although on my first listen I found it downright irritating (I was in my car), when I played it at work, I found it intriguing. <
> <
>The Naked City hardcore pieces are performed by a band called Prelapse, with Zorn guesting on two tracks. The total length of the three pieces is just about two and a half minutes, and they're about what you'd expect-- frantic, cross genre blasts. When Zorn doesn't play, there seems to be a distinct lack of personality on the material that leaves me wondering how much Naked City was the sum of its parts and how much Naked City was purely a reflection of Zorn (I suspect somewhere in between is the case). <
> <
>The remaining three pieces are pretty diverse-- opener "Fils des Etoiles", performed by Anthony Coleman on celeste and Cyro Baptista on percussion and vocal is kind of hard to describe-- it's certainly interesting enough, Baptista sort of half chants over a lovely celeste performance and hand percussion. The remaining two pieces are far easier to digest-- "Dreamer of Dreams", performed by a trio of Marc Ribot (guitar), Erik Friedlander (cello), and Greg Cohen (bass) sounds like an extra piece from "Bar Kokhba". Ribot is smokey and bluesy, and unusually sensitive and his performance is the highlight here, and this also seems to point the way to "The Gift". Closer "Sooki's Lullaby", performed on "celeste music box" by Coleman, is a pretty music box melody that is delicate an quiet, and a nice reprieve after the twenty minutes of rushing wind on "Cycles du Nord". <
> <
>overall, "Music For Children" is a fine record, it lacks that certain something that Zorn's best work has, but its well worth a listen.

---

A mysterious album for adults
There are few albums as diverse as this one. It's a real challenge for any listener. There are three less-than-a-minute tracks of aggressive, hardcore jazz/rock. Then there's the title track, which starts off with a string quartet and ends with the sounds of splitered wood and whip cracks. Cycles du Nord is over ten minutes of wind --- yes, ten minutes of wind. Then there's the music box song, a bit of Latin guitar, and a little lullaby on percussion and celeste.

Buy this if you're feeling VERY adventurous. If not, try Taboo & Exile first. Or The Gift. Those albums have the same format --- lots of different musical styles, including sound effects and noisy stuff --- but they are more accessible.