Cheap American Experience - Abraham and Mary Lincoln: A House Divided (DVD) (David Grubin) Price

Related Products

Customer Reviews of American Experience - Abraham and Mary Lincoln: A House Divided

Ties That Bind
I found this to be an excellent documentary. Informative, unsentimental, and moving, the film makes these iconic figures human without losing sight of their historical importance. Holly Hunter as the voice of Mary Lincoln is really genius in her portrayal of the beleaguered First Lady. David Morse as Lincoln also does a fine job and the contemporary photographs are well chosen. For a three disc set this is a bargain and as a "Linconphile" I have watched it many times. Particularly interesting are the comments of Doris Kearns Goodwin and David Herbert Donald - both noted Lincoln biographers. Highly reccommended.

---

Very well done!! Excellent!
This is an excellent dvd. The depth of the information presented is the best I've seen thus far! I have only one criticism of it -- there was no mention of the conspiracy to kill Lincoln!! That's why I gave it 4 stars instead of 5. However, either A&E or the History Channel did a fantastic job in portraying the plot to kill Lincoln and also would be worth investing in. It had the whole elaborate plan about how Boothe conspired to kill not only Lincoln, but the vice president and the secretary of state as well. Between the two products, you would have an excellent representation of what actually happened. After seeing both these dvds, I can honestly say I was glad to know that Boothe had been shot!! Not that I advocate shooting anyone for any reason!! <
> <
>The material on this particular dvd was very well presented and used some reenactment scenes. I enjoyed hearing all the views of each of the historians as the information given brought it more to life than just reading about it! <
> <
>In my opinion, this dvd was very definitely well worth the price and I would highly recommend it!

---

Fine treatment of a somewhat neglected aspect of Lincoln
It has often been observed that Abraham Lincoln has been enshrined to the point of deification. During the recent Ronald Reagan obsequies, rituals laden with religious references, we the television viewers were treated again & again to images of the Lincoln Memorial, as though Lincoln himself were some sort of national demigod to whom proper deference must be rendered from time to time. All this has served to strip away much of Lincoln's humanity, to the point that we find it hard to believe that he was, just as most of us are, an ordinary spouse & parent, trying to balance the demands of home with the demands of work.

This documentary helps to remind us of that side of Lincoln, as we see the young ambitious lawyer/politician & his equally ambitious wife struggle to make a life together. It is a story, above everything else, of great personal loss (for both Abraham & Mary Lincoln), and at times it makes this documentary painful to watch. As one watches Abraham Lincoln cope the overwhelming stress of a wartime presidency, having already lost two children, one yearns for the time when Abraham & Mary Lincoln can finally, even for a little while, relax in retirement and enjoy each other's company once again, without the demands of the office to distract them. Despite knowing it never did happen, I found myself feeling this way. Of course, the story takes the viewer through to a marriage ended by murder & a subsequent emotional collapse. It is exhausting to watch.

The documentary provides a great amount of detail. Some have complained that one sees the same images of the Lincolns over and over again, although I would think that after "The Civil War," people would be used to seeing an unending series of still photos on the television screen. It comes with the territory, and unless you want actors dramatizing the life of the Lincolns, you really have little choice in presentation. My only objection with the documentary is that it is a little too sympathetic at times. For example, the fact that the Lincolns were not particularly good parents is overlooked. Even in the best of times, Robert Lincoln's relationship with his parents was ambivalent, and was sometimes downright chilly. Tad Lincoln, on the other hand, was so spoiled and overindulged that by the time he was around 12, he was a virtual illiterate because his parents didn't have the heart to make him attend to his studies. One gets no sense of this in the documentary.

Everyone loves a happy ending, but unfortunately there really isn't one to be found here. However, the saddest tales generally are the ones that leave the most lasting impact. One cannot watch this story without being deeply moved.